Since the Naval Academy in Annapolis was founded in 1845, a chaplain has said grace before the midshipmen’s mandatory noon mealtime. Now, the American Civil Liberties Union is threatening legal action if the academy doesn’t end the tradition.

Nine of the 4,200 midshipmen approached the ACLU for help in stopping the practice recently; they feel the prayer violates their constitutional rights. The academy has been faced with complaints and petitions about the issue numerous times in the past, but has always stood firm in its position.

An academy spokesman said: “The Academy does not intend to change its practice of offering Midshipmen an opportunity for prayer or devotional thought during noon meal announcements.”

However, the Naval Academy stands alone among military colleges. All others have halted the practice of mealtime prayer (although prayers are often still included during special events like graduation).

Several West Point cadets recently complained about prayers during banquets. West Point’s spokesman, a colonel, responded to their complaint via e-mail to the New York Times: “During a very few big events each year, such as the 500th-night banquet and graduation we have a nondenominational invocation and benediction. That is all. Not during breakfast. Not during lunch. Not during dinner. Not in a box. Not with a fox. Not in a house. Not with a mouse.”

Who knew Army colonels had a sense of humor?

Back in Annapolis, midshipmen are required to stand at parade rest during the lunchtime prayer. Although not required to bow their heads, some say they would feel ostracized if they didn’t. One recent graduate said: “When everyone around you is doing that, especially as a plebe, it’s very domineering and kind of scary if you don’t wish to participate.”

If the academy doesn’t respond favorably to the ACLU’s request, a lawsuit may be the next step.

So what do you all think? Time-honored tradition or infringement of civil liberties?

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.