• Advertisement

    • video still
    • video still
    • video still
    • video still
    • video still
    • video still
  • Advertisement

Did eminent domain ruin Baltimore?

by Lori Barrett | June 24, 2008 at 1:11 pm
Posted in Uncategorized

A Loyola College professor believes Baltimore’s overuse of eminent domain, coupled with exorbitant property taxes, are the major factors contributing to the decline of the city that began in the 1960s.

Stephen Walters’ study, Baltimore’s Flawed Renaissance, was recently published by a libertarian law firm, Institute for Justice. He paints Baltimore as a tale of two cities: one is a thriving waterfront, while the rest has been abandoned by residents fleeing the city for the suburbs over the past fifty years.

In the study, Walters essentially dismisses high crime rates and bad schools as the reasons for the exodus from the city to the suburbs. Instead, he says: “The city’s lack of progress on so many fronts is a direct by-product of its failure to understand and treat the real source of its problems: hostility to private property rights and a resulting flight of capital that largely drained the city of its economic lifeblood.”

Crime and other ills are thus a result of the government’s flawed redevelopment strategy for blighted neighborhoods, according to Walters — strategies that included bulldozing entire neighborhoods to build highways. (Highways that sometimes went nowhere, it must be added.)

I haven’t had time yet today to read the entirety of Walters’ 25-page study, but what I have skimmed so far offers an interesting perspective on our city. However, as noted in the Sun article by another local economist, the study may be “wrong on its face” as it ignores a number of other factors, including the suburbanization of jobs.

Anyway, if you have some time to kill this afternoon, you can download the study here as a PDF and share your reactions.


You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

 

5 responses.

  1. Hey don't forget the highway to nowhere, Route 70 edition!

  2. Dear god, this study is a wonderful read:

    Imagine the creative energy that would have been unleashed if, for the last half-century, entrepreneurs knew that the city
    tax collector would not confiscate the value they would create in turning around a decaying neighborhood with new shops or condos. Imagine the infusions of capital that would have occurred if every investor - from the developer thinking of building an office or entertainment complex to the individual homeowner deciding whether to renovate in the city or beat it to the suburbs — got the same incentives extended to the
    well-connected players involved in planners’ chosen redevelopment areas.

  3. I don't think that was the only problem in Baltimore, just about every city in the north east suffered some sort of "white flight" that left them in disrepair and just recently trying to lure people back in. When the suburbs were built resources and land where cheap and plenty. With the rising cost of the energy needed to sustain the suburban life more people are looking to come back to the city and to some extent smaller towns.

  4. Gentrification is not the answer, which is the general approach with eminent domain, bring in shopping, tourism, and more expensive housing...

    Let's bring back living wage unskilled labor jobs. Baltimore more used to be a city of industry and port activity, now all these jobs are overseas or run by foreign companies that pay minimum wage with no benefits. Poverty is hell on a city. We need to bring back the middle class, not increase the divide between rich and poor.

  5. Eminent domain is bad, yes - but that's not the problem with Baltimore. The problem is BLACK people. Whites (and other non-blacks) CAN stand a lot of crime, even eminent domain, but they can't stand to send their kids to a 99.9% black school - doesn't matter if the school is good. Why? Because their kid will get his/her ass kicked, shot, get pregnant via rape, catch v.d., and/or get hooked on hard drugs. This is not racism, this is race related facts based on statistics. Baltimore is a cesspool of drug addicts, v.d. carriers, rapists, thieves, murderers, and stoned out of their mind hippies. DO NOT LIVE HERE if you are not one of the above.